Saturday, July 12, 2014

Poisoning the Atmosphere

So, here's my question for this section:  why not just include it in the last?  What makes it deserving of its own title?  I mean, other than the beautiful "fishing expedition" transition on p. 91, and a clever transition with "pickles and mayonnaise" (Aside: did you know that it is the ability to use effective transitions that will increase the coherence and cohesion of your writing and make the people who score standardized testing "oooh" and "aaaah" in wonderment and glee?) and the transition between sections with the words "flickering," "feeble," and "fatal", why not just hitch it to the section before or after it? I ask you.  It's a strange little section.

Poisoning the Atmosphere: #Workingconditions #irony #thirdentry today


Poisoning the Atmosphere

Don't know why this is blank.  Sorry, People.

Dyeing and Dying

For this entry, I thought I might just show you what my notes look like as I read.

Hmmm....nice transitional knife metaphor to link the section on surgery to pharmacological therapy.  Visualize chemo as a tiny knife that cuts out cancer cells.

Definition of specificity: the ability of any medicine to discriminate between its intended target and its host.  Chemistry is cool.

Back to the beginning with the textile industry. 

William Perkin:  "boiling nitric acid and benzene in smuggled glass flasks"  Breaking Bad.

Gideon Harvey, expert in the field of insulting others.    Seems kind of uncalled for to me.  No need to get personal. Jeez.

Vitalism: the belief that the chemistry of living organisms was imbued (nice word) with some mystical property, a vital essence that could not be duplicated in a laboratory.

"Wohler only needed to take a short day-trip from his laboratory in Gottingen to the labs of Frankfort."  Communication between disciplines, between scientists and other professionals is key.  It makes me wonder what other sorts of miracles are sitting on a shelf somewhere waiting for someone to stumble upon them and provide the missing piece to some great discovery.

Ehrlich: "The biological universe was full of molecules picking out their partners like clever locks designed to fit a key; toxins clinging inseparably to antitoxins, dyes that highlighted only particular pairs of cells, chemical stains that could nimbly pick out one class of germs from a mixture of microbes." 
"rant in a train compartment"  "Chemotherapy" was conceptually born in the middle of the night.

"Syphillis--the secret malady."

Ehrlich- magic bullets.

Mustard Gas and the Krumbhaars:  again communication.  I guess it's important to read the "second tier" journals too.

"That their bullet would eventually appear out of that very chemical weapon seemed like a perversion of specific affinity, a ghoulish distortion of Ehrlich's dream" (88).  Circle back to page 38  " A cancer cell is  an astonishing perversion of the normal cell." And page 6, "If we seek immortality , then so, too, in a rather perverse sense sense, does the cancer cell."

So, after taking these notes, I might sit down and type up my blog entry and try to make some sense of what I just read. You might try this same strategy.  It  will produce a valuable set of notes upon which to reflect before test day.

The Hard Tube and the Weak Light

Let me start by saying that this section is a test writer's dream. Mukherjee presents the material in a way that makes it very easy to compose test questions.  For example, the anecdote about Rontgen and his wife would make a nice little essay question as would the bit about the Radium Girls.  Did you know that is a play by the way? I'm ten seconds away from ordering it as I am always curious to see how an author takes a historical event and fleshes it out making characters and a story line come to life.  I am always interested in the author's rhetorical choices which is why I always like to read or watch multiple interpretations of a work.

Another beautiful question could come from the paradox that is radiation therapy: "the promise and the peril".

And then, anytime an author takes the time to list something, that list can very easily be turned into a multiple choice question.  For example, on page 77, Mukherjee discusses the inherent limits of radiation medicine giving the reader obvious cues such as "the first of these limitations" and "the second limit."  That language makes the teacher's job very easy.  The question almost writes itself.

Then, of course, there are all the noteworthy folks in this section who would lend themselves to inclusion in a matching section: Emil Grubbe, Rontgen, the Curies.

And guess who's back: Galen.  After this explanation of surgery and radiation as forms of treatment and the limitations of both, Mukherjee has to get us back to the idea of "systemic" treatment: Chemo.  So, he includes an anecdote about Willy Meyer to transition back to the beginning.  A really nice question might be: Explain the way in which Galen's humor theory of cancer was correct.  And incorrect.  So, look at the parallel we've got going on at the end here.  The paradox of radiation therapy, the "physical penalty" and "mistaken kindness" paradox of surgery and then Galen who was right and wrong at the same time.  This will take us to the "biologic systemic" after treatment idea that Willie Meyer discusses in his letter: chemotherapy.

Best sentence of the section:  "Pierre and Marie......had met at the Sorbonne and been drawn to each other because of a common interest in magnetism" (74).  Oh, Mukherjee.

I'll end with a question:  Is it possible for one's cheeks to fall out?  Look at the top of page 75 and tell me what you think of that sentence.

Wednesday, July 9, 2014

Going to Chicago

I'll write at you Friday morning.  I'll cover 73-88 that day.  I'm ready for someone else to volunteer after that.  Don't be shy.  Let me know.

Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Halstedt

I can't figure out if I am supposed to like him or not.  But, I don't think I do.  I think he would be good friends with Aldous Huxley if the two were to meet. They'd be good bowling partners.  I'm pretty sure that I wouldn't want my surgeon to be a cocaine or morphine addict.  By the time Mukherjee describes him as "tender, almost paternal" on page 66, it's a bit too late for me as a reader to establish a liking for Halstedt even if he does "challenge cancer to duel with his knife" with a vigor unlike anyone else we've met up until this point.

If "mistaken kindness" was about leaving too much cancerous tissue behind, I think the same term could be applied to Halstedt and the "physical penalty"that his patients paid.  That is, depending on his motivation. But I must admit, by the time Mukherjee explains Halstedt's "conceptual error," I feel a bit sorry for him.  How could he have known? Shortly after I am thrown back again into the Halstedt Haters Camp because he and his students "clutched to their theories" so "adamantly".  I just don't know what to think about that guy.

More later.