So, Mukherjee opens with the short narrative about Hunter and the surgical success he had with "movable cancers" in order to introduce the two problems that surgeons had prior to 1846 and the solutions to those problems. Thank goodness for William Morton and his little glass vaporizer, first of all. But, I think the thing that is most noteworthy about this section is the way that Joseph Lister takes the work of someone else--Pasteur-- and uses logic to reach a conclusion about infection. And then, of course, the impact of these two discoveries on the treatment of cancer goes without saying. Mukherjee, ever the obliging author, takes the reader one step further in his explanation of the impact of these two discoveries by way of a comparative example: surgeon and musician, Theodor Billroth. With the discoveries of anesthesia and antiseptic, Billroth was able to to do much more invasive surgery than Hunter who could only offer "remote sympathy."
"But what if the whole of cancer could be uprooted at its earliest stage using the most definitive surgery conceivable?"
Spoiler Alert: This entire section shows us the progression of the treatment of cancer, but it also sets the reader up for a very "radical" approach in the treatment of breast cancer. I mean, hey, as long as we have antiseptic and anesthetic, let's try to "uproot" the cancer no matter how much of the patient we might have to sacrifice. Right? Thankfully, today, although a woman diagnosed with breast cancer may still have to undergo a complete mastectomy, it is not the "go to" procedure. There are other, more conservative, treatments as you will find out.
I like to envision Mukherjee setting up this part of the text. I imagine his thought process. "Okay. We have to talk about Halstedt next. But in order to get to Halstedt, the audience needs to know about advances in the field of surgery itself and how those advances would inform or allow Halstedt's radical ideas. So, I need an example pre-antiseptic and pre-anesthetic and then I need a post-antiseptic and post anesthetic example (enter Hunter and Billroth) so that the reader can understand how Halstedt's idea would then be an acceptable choice." Of course, I am not sure that that is what he was thinking, but given the evidence in the text, I think it is a reasonable theory. What do you think?
Can you tell I'm sleepy tonight? I just said goodbye to the last of the in-laws who were here as guests in the house for five days. On the 4th of July there were 27 people in this house. They ate 32 hot dogs, four lbs of burger, two boxes of pasta salad, two giant cans of baked beans, a half of a sheet cake, two pies, two large bags of chips, an entire vegetable tray, except for the broccoli and the cauliflower (why does no one ever eat that part?), eight liters of soda.....it was like the descent of the locusts. Not going to lie, it was five days of fun, but a lot of work. A lot of work. I meant to say that twice. I am the head chef. I can't imagine the mutiny around here if I were to suggest a bowl of cereal for dinner. I'm exhausted and my husband is telling me we might want to go into the basement now because apparently there is a weather situation brewing? Which means I'll have to haul the rabbit cage downstairs so that my 6 six year old doesn't freak out about the safety of the family pet. His name is Bon Bon. He's French, so plug your nose when you say his name. So, there you have it. Goodnight all. I promise a more energized entry tomorrow :)
Sunday, July 6, 2014
Thank you, Owen Purdue. Who is next?
Onkos
Immediately what stands out to me in this chapter, (as they do in most) are the beginning quotations. Mukherjee’s prolific use of quotations in the book is one of my favorite things about his work. They pull you in, make you think deeply. Anyways, the ones at the beginning of ‘Onkos’ are very good. We have Galen, the famous follower of Hippocrates’ ‘four humours’ theory. He said this in 130 AD: Black bile without boiling causes cancers. It’s hard to understand what he means, and I was left with a lot of questions after reading this quotation: what is black bile? How does it form into cancer? In any case I moved on.
The next quotation is much more poignant. We have learned nothing, therefore, about the real cause of Cancer or its actual nature. We are where the Greeks were. That last statement is highlighted simply because it is so poignant. Francis Wood said this in 1914, over two millennia after Hippocrates and the first description of Karkinos. That statement, in its beautiful simplicity, tells us of the unknowably complicated mechanisms of cancer. Cancer is so intricate, so huge and massive and unknowable, that even in the 20th century we were only at the tip of the iceberg in our understanding of it. That statement again makes cancer real to the reader.
Mukherjee hits hard with a final, poignant statement: In some ways disease does not exist until we have agreed that it does- by perceiving, naming, and responding to it. This quotation confirms the inevitable, that confirmation bias (denying bad news) is human nature. It makes me think about what I would do if I was diagnosed with cancer. I would probably try to deny it as long as I could. This is not my fault. I, after all, am only human.
On to the actual text, where we are forced to confront the question ‘what’s in a name?’ Well, in a name is precisely this: potential. If it’s a person, it could be the potential to smile at old memories or frown in disgust. The same goes for just about anything….Except illnesses. There are famous names in the world of medicine: HIV/AIDS, influenza, ebola, smallpox, (yes it has been eradicated, but who of us hasn’t considered an apocalyptic resurgence?) and of course, cancer.
These are the names that send chills down the spine, names that give meaning to the word fear. And as Mukherjee tells us in the opening paragraph of the chapter, to name an illness is to give it literary weight. A great piece of wisdom here: A patient, long before he becomes the subject of medical scrutiny, is, at first, simply a storyteller, a narrator of suffering. Quite awesome.
Mukherjee then takes us on an etymological tour of medicine. We see here how much we really owe to the romans and greeks. Tuberculosis, influenza, and now cancer: we all see what’s behind their names. In telling us about the origins of these names, Mukherjee uses his signature device to keep us interested in the story: he changes the time in history. The last chapter was all about the beginning, and discovery of cancer: this one seems to be about the naming of the disease and its very first scientific hypothesis. And if you’ll flip the page back, you can see we left off first in 1990 with Aufderheide and then in 1940, as cancer ‘ratcheted its way to second on the list’. Now, here we are again, back in 400 BC with Hippocrates and the genesis of the four humour theory. We learn in this chapter the reason there’s a crab on the cover of the book: to the first man who described it, Hippocrates, cancer was the sharp, rough shell of a crab, and the tumors not single, isolated metastasized outcroppings but legs reaching out around the body. And so it was, that here today in 2014 there is a crab on the cover of the book. The title of the chapter is credited to the Greek word for ‘mass’ or ‘load’: onkos, from which the modern discipline of oncology takes its name. Mukherjee reminds us, though, that Hippocrates description covered not just cancer, but included every other tumor: lumps lumped indiscriminately into the same category of pathology. There was a bit of english magic at the beginning of this clause, did you notice it? Hopefully.
Next we hear of the ‘four humors’ hypothesis, theorized by Hippocrates and picked up by Galen a couple centuries later. For every illness there was a liquid explanation, but for cancer, there was one perfectly in synch more with the future than the past: that cancer was a malevolent, evil disease; that it came hand in hand with depression, darkness, and death. Here is a metaphor with some of the deepest roots in all of medical history. It tells us that the chill we feel when we think of cancer is the same one that has been chilling people for all of human history. This may be a short chapter, but there is a lot of material here. It’s also worth mentioning that we get the name of the section (Of Black Cholor, Without Boyling) from a quotation by Thomas Gale, english surgeon, describing the cancer hypothesis of Galen.
But perhaps because of the humor theory, the treatment of cancer took a step back. Because tumors were now believed to be caused by black bile, the potential of successfully excising them was...Next to nothing. ‘The problem with treating cancer surgically, Galen suggested, was that black bile was everywhere, as inevitable and pervasive as any fluid. You could cut cancer out, but the bile would flow right back, like sap seeping through the limbs of a tree.’ And that is where we leave cancer research for a long, long time. Almost 1500 years will pass before the humor theory is finally discredited. Mukherjee throws in some of his trademark visuals here, describing the painful tradition of medieval surgery, and gives us part of the reason cancer treatment was left to a standstill for a millenium and a half: that surgery was often life-threatening.
Suddenly, on the last page, we are met with a flurry of one of the rhetorical devices Siddhartha Mukherjee loves best: anaphora. With little restraint he lists off a dozen or so of the medieval ‘cures’, showing us just how far medieval patients would go to find a cure for their tumors. What is the purpose of this veritable apothecary? Perhaps to tell us exactly the lengths patients exhausted before succumbing to their diseases or the operation of a surgeon. Indeed, it’s really only a sampling of the amount of drugs available to people now and the ones that were available to them then. Mukherjee ends the chapter with a final metaphor: that the human body with its surplus of ‘black bile’ was like an overfull sponge. It’s a metaphor that’s eerily reminiscent of Mukherjee’s description of leukemia at the beginning of the book: much like black bile, white blood cells saturate the leukemic body with cancerous ‘blasts’. Maybe Galen wasn’t so far off the mark after all?
Vanishing Humors
Info:
|
Significance:
|
- In 1533, a student named Andreas Vesalius arrived at the University of Paris.
|
- He hoped to learn Galenic medicine, but would end up disproving Galen entirely.
|
-When he arrived, he found that the University’s surgical program was neglected and in disarray.
|
- He resolved to teach himself the principles of anatomy without the help of the university.
|
-Vesalius began to visit graveyards around Paris, looking for subjects...
|
-From which to make his own anatomical map.
|
-He began to chart out arteries, veins, and nerves.
|
-Soon, though, he was forced to confront a major hole in Galen’s hypothesis. Galen had mentioned to the readers of his works that in order to cure disease one would have to bleed patients from the arteries that led ‘straight into’ the tumor. But what defined ‘straight into’?
|
-Because of that question, Galen set out sketching every nerve and artery in the human body.
|
- Soon he was charting out the nerves and many other systems. Nowhere, however, could he find the ‘Black bile’ of cancer. Though he would succeed in his mission of mapping out the body, he would never formally declare himself against Galen’s principles. The fact that black bile didn’t exist, however, always lurked in the back of his mind.
|
- 250 years later, in 1793, Matthew Baillie would publish a counter to Galen’s study, in which instead of showing healthy anatomy, he drew the anatomy of the ill.
|
-Here was the finale of the search for Galen’s black bile. Surely, if black bile was present, it would be present in something it was supposed to have caused, cancerous tumors.
|
-Baillie sketched out several types of cancer. But none of them contained black bile.
|
-It was concluded by the scientific community that black bile, and Galen’s four humor hypothesis, did not exist.
|
Friday, July 4, 2014
Happy Fourth of July!!!!!
Guest blogger tomorrow!!!!!
So, today I got the inside scoop from a member of the Harvard College Admissions Board and the Harvard College Medical School Admissions Board (not sure if that is what it is called exactly). The undergrad board member told me that the number one trait that he looks for in an applicant's admission essay is sincerity, an authentic and effective writing voice in an essay that is well-organized with a clear thesis. The med school person told me that the quality of writing on an applicant's personal statement can make or break his/her application.
Interesting.
So, today I got the inside scoop from a member of the Harvard College Admissions Board and the Harvard College Medical School Admissions Board (not sure if that is what it is called exactly). The undergrad board member told me that the number one trait that he looks for in an applicant's admission essay is sincerity, an authentic and effective writing voice in an essay that is well-organized with a clear thesis. The med school person told me that the quality of writing on an applicant's personal statement can make or break his/her application.
Interesting.
Thursday, July 3, 2014
A Private Plague: Other content
Here are Mukherjee's quotations:
"We reveal ourselves in the metaphors we choose for depicting the cosmos in miniature."....Augustus and his cigarette.
"Now it is cancer's turn to be the disease that doesn't knock before it enters." Susan Sontag
Here's a quotation I'd like to add.....
"We reveal ourselves in the metaphors we choose for depicting the cosmos in miniature."....Augustus and his cigarette.
"Now it is cancer's turn to be the disease that doesn't knock before it enters." Susan Sontag
Here's a quotation I'd like to add.....
And I'd like to give you the following page numbers: 259, 286, 289, 459. An interesting rhetorical choice occurs on these pages. For an English teacher's idea of fun, see if you can figure out what it is. Oh, and why it is so subtly beautiful. It's okay to be wrong, by the way. It's not okay to not be wrong because you didn't take a risk and give it your best educated guess. I mean, where is the growth in that?
This chapter seems to me to look at cancer through the lens of literary criticism with its discussion of "the disease of poets", the comparison of the two diseases and the ways in which each is reflective of its age. That would make a great essay question. I'll have to remember that.
Mukherjee circles back again to Virchow in his explanation of omnis cellula e cellula (TFIOS). Hint: if the teacher mentions people, terms and events in her writing of the summer blog....it would probably be a good idea to hold yourself accountable for knowing all about those people, terms and events. He sets us up to go way back in time to the first recorded documentation of cancer...on papyrus, of course, the teachings of Imhotep, the story of Atossa.
The most important thing about this chapter is that we get an explanation for why, all of a sudden, it seems like cancer is moving up to the top of the list of diseases that kill. But what we get with all the history is as Mukherjee concludes, "the feeling that one has encountered a powerful monster in its infancy" (45).
Your thoughts? Reactions? Ideas? What does this section make you think?
The most important thing about this chapter is that we get an explanation for why, all of a sudden, it seems like cancer is moving up to the top of the list of diseases that kill. But what we get with all the history is as Mukherjee concludes, "the feeling that one has encountered a powerful monster in its infancy" (45).
Your thoughts? Reactions? Ideas? What does this section make you think?
A [not so] Private Plague
Does the literal definition of metastasis seem like an understatement to anyone else? It does to me.
I'd like to linger a minute there and on the idea of the "clonally evolving disease" to deliver some news. Some of you may know Ms. Engelhardt, science teacher at Northern High. Many of you may not know that she and I are close friends. I have been close to her side through two rounds of trying to cut out or obliterate "clonally evolving" cells through surgeries and chemotherapy. Metastasis: literally "beyond stillness." Hmph. I asked her if I could talk about her in this blog with all of you. She was all for it. Through all of her struggles with cancer, she has made it her personal mission to educate people, to share her experiences and to find something positive, some light in the dark.
The thing is that when a person receives news in the privacy of the oncologist's office, the same news....again, for the third time, it can be difficult to make the private public, to share news with those who have stood beside you time and again, to let them know that once again the troops must be rallied and the ammunition must be gathered.
So, this phenomenon that Mukherjee describes, "Every generation of cancer cells creates a small number of cells that is genetically different from its parents.When a chemotherapeutic drug or the immune system attacks cancer, mutant clones that can resist the attack grow out. The fittest cancer cell survives", today I'm wondering if this is what's going on with Ms. Engelhardt. Her cancer it seems has evolved in this way. This coming Monday and Wednesday I will be accompanying her to a series of appointments to learn about the ammunition that will be used this time. She wants people to know. She doesn't mind if people talk about it or talk with her about it. The hardest part for her was informing people....again. So, hopefully, this blog entry makes all of that a bit easier. It might be difficult for some of you to know what to say at this point. If that is the case, but you want to talk further, you can always email me. Or you could email Ms. Engelhardt. Throughout this journey, she has always welcomed and accepted open discussion and support from anyone who is comfortable giving it.
More on the actual content of this section later.
I'd like to linger a minute there and on the idea of the "clonally evolving disease" to deliver some news. Some of you may know Ms. Engelhardt, science teacher at Northern High. Many of you may not know that she and I are close friends. I have been close to her side through two rounds of trying to cut out or obliterate "clonally evolving" cells through surgeries and chemotherapy. Metastasis: literally "beyond stillness." Hmph. I asked her if I could talk about her in this blog with all of you. She was all for it. Through all of her struggles with cancer, she has made it her personal mission to educate people, to share her experiences and to find something positive, some light in the dark.
The thing is that when a person receives news in the privacy of the oncologist's office, the same news....again, for the third time, it can be difficult to make the private public, to share news with those who have stood beside you time and again, to let them know that once again the troops must be rallied and the ammunition must be gathered.
So, this phenomenon that Mukherjee describes, "Every generation of cancer cells creates a small number of cells that is genetically different from its parents.When a chemotherapeutic drug or the immune system attacks cancer, mutant clones that can resist the attack grow out. The fittest cancer cell survives", today I'm wondering if this is what's going on with Ms. Engelhardt. Her cancer it seems has evolved in this way. This coming Monday and Wednesday I will be accompanying her to a series of appointments to learn about the ammunition that will be used this time. She wants people to know. She doesn't mind if people talk about it or talk with her about it. The hardest part for her was informing people....again. So, hopefully, this blog entry makes all of that a bit easier. It might be difficult for some of you to know what to say at this point. If that is the case, but you want to talk further, you can always email me. Or you could email Ms. Engelhardt. Throughout this journey, she has always welcomed and accepted open discussion and support from anyone who is comfortable giving it.
More on the actual content of this section later.
Tuesday, July 1, 2014
Farber's Gauntlet
So, the reason that I am a bit behind now is that I issued a challenge to Jessi Singh who had sent me an email expressing his concern about the kind of notes he was taking. The challenge was to write the next blog entry and he took me up on it. So, it was only fair to give him a little time to do that. You can find his notes here.
I think Jesse deserves an "Atta Boy" for being willing to take this risk. As you can see, he did an excellent job of summarizing the main ideas of this section demonstrating his comprehension of the main ideas in the text. The thing I find most noteworthy is that Jesse has outlined a cause and effect analysis of the contents. I think that one of the coolest things that could happen this summer is for each of you to find one or two study partners and take turns taking notes in this way and then for all of you to discuss them somehow. Discuss the different things that each of you noticed as important that might have been left out of the notes, etc. What a great way to internalize what you've read. In the meantime, I'd welcome another guest blogger here. It is waaaaaaay more fun to read what my future students write than for me to read my own thoughts.
You may have noticed that this section contains the narrative of the boy to whom Mukherjee dedicated the book. If I were to guess, I wonder if, in part, the reason for that is that Farber's work with Sandler was the first case of a remission which marks a turning point in the history of cancer. This section is kind of painful to read as it horrifies me to think of people being injected with chemicals (prior to the Nuremberg consent code) without their knowledge or if they are minors without the knowledge of their parents or guardians. Yikes.
Absolutely my favorite part of this section, however, is Mukherjee's rhetorical analysis of the paper mentioned in Jesse's notes. A rhetorical analysis is an analysis of the tools that a writer uses to get his ideas across. It notes the date of publication, the structure, the organization, text features, modes of discourse, the style of diction (word choice), the length, the tone, the purpose, the message or argument.
Length: seven pages
Published: June 3, 1948
Features: "packed with tables, figures, microscope photographs, laboratory values and blood counts
Diction: starched, formal, detached and scientific yet exciting
" Yet like all great medical papers, it was a page-turner. And like all good novels, it was timeless: to read it today is to be pitched behind the scenes into the tumultuous life of the Boston clinic....."
Message: Cancer, even in its most aggressive form, had been treated with a medicine, a chemical.
Tone: Hopeful "He was throwing down a gauntlet for cancer medicine."
Well, this worked beautifully. Jesse helped pick out the important facts and then I was able to layer on some of the stuff we will be working on no matter the text in AP Lang. Anyone up for taking on the next section? A Private Plague? Hopefully, you won't look at the challenge as your own private plague. Let me know. Soon. Otherwise, I'll be back tomorrow.
For those of you who may be getting annoyed with the fact that we are a bit behind the seven pages, you can keep plugging away. The blog will then be a nice daily review for you. Honestly, all my in-laws are coming into town to stay with us tomorrow and I am doing the best I can to keep all the balls in the air at this point :)
Have a great night.
I think Jesse deserves an "Atta Boy" for being willing to take this risk. As you can see, he did an excellent job of summarizing the main ideas of this section demonstrating his comprehension of the main ideas in the text. The thing I find most noteworthy is that Jesse has outlined a cause and effect analysis of the contents. I think that one of the coolest things that could happen this summer is for each of you to find one or two study partners and take turns taking notes in this way and then for all of you to discuss them somehow. Discuss the different things that each of you noticed as important that might have been left out of the notes, etc. What a great way to internalize what you've read. In the meantime, I'd welcome another guest blogger here. It is waaaaaaay more fun to read what my future students write than for me to read my own thoughts.
You may have noticed that this section contains the narrative of the boy to whom Mukherjee dedicated the book. If I were to guess, I wonder if, in part, the reason for that is that Farber's work with Sandler was the first case of a remission which marks a turning point in the history of cancer. This section is kind of painful to read as it horrifies me to think of people being injected with chemicals (prior to the Nuremberg consent code) without their knowledge or if they are minors without the knowledge of their parents or guardians. Yikes.
Absolutely my favorite part of this section, however, is Mukherjee's rhetorical analysis of the paper mentioned in Jesse's notes. A rhetorical analysis is an analysis of the tools that a writer uses to get his ideas across. It notes the date of publication, the structure, the organization, text features, modes of discourse, the style of diction (word choice), the length, the tone, the purpose, the message or argument.
Length: seven pages
Published: June 3, 1948
Features: "packed with tables, figures, microscope photographs, laboratory values and blood counts
Diction: starched, formal, detached and scientific yet exciting
" Yet like all great medical papers, it was a page-turner. And like all good novels, it was timeless: to read it today is to be pitched behind the scenes into the tumultuous life of the Boston clinic....."
Message: Cancer, even in its most aggressive form, had been treated with a medicine, a chemical.
Tone: Hopeful "He was throwing down a gauntlet for cancer medicine."
Well, this worked beautifully. Jesse helped pick out the important facts and then I was able to layer on some of the stuff we will be working on no matter the text in AP Lang. Anyone up for taking on the next section? A Private Plague? Hopefully, you won't look at the challenge as your own private plague. Let me know. Soon. Otherwise, I'll be back tomorrow.
For those of you who may be getting annoyed with the fact that we are a bit behind the seven pages, you can keep plugging away. The blog will then be a nice daily review for you. Honestly, all my in-laws are coming into town to stay with us tomorrow and I am doing the best I can to keep all the balls in the air at this point :)
Have a great night.
Sunday, June 29, 2014
Coming Soon: More about the monster more insatiable.
Just let me say for now, one of my favorite minor characters in the book is Yellapragada Subbarao.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)