Sunday, June 29, 2014

"A monster more insatiable than the guillotine." Or , "How am I already behind on the third day?"

Is anyone with me on that?

The title of this section has, well, I'll just say it: a special place in my heart.  So much of our required reading for high school is about monsters, literal and figurative. Beowulf fights an actual monster which happens to symbolize the very literal threat of invaders during and prior to Anglo-Saxon times. Macbeth is just a monster of a man.  Or is his wife the one I should be calling the monster?  Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.  The Canterbury Tales.  We are always reading about monsters because as much as there is that is good and positive in the world, there is and always will be something threatening out there to deal with.  Every day we try to tame our own personal monsters.  CNN and other news sources bring us tales of monsters abroad and the ways in which they torment the entire globe.  Luckily, we have language.  Language, it seems to me, is a powerful weapon in the fight against monsters.  Rhetorical tools are equal to the arsenal of weapons at your disposal to identify the monsters, to create awareness, to propose solutions, to decrease the power they have over us.  I think they feed off silence.

Someone let me know if you can access that link up there.





Things I Noticed: "A suppuration of blood"

So, in the last section, I noticed that Mukherjee established his research questions.  "How old is cancer? What are the roots of the battle against this disease?  Or as patients often asked me: Where are we in the 'war' on cancer?  How did we get here? Is there an end?  Can this war even be won?"

He then tells us that he "used the past to explain the present" which is exactly what happens in the "suppuration of blood" section.  This is where he begins to set up his recursive text structure taking us first to the man that he sees as one of the key figures in the history of cancer: Sidney Farber.

At the beginning of this section, we find ourselves in the lab with Sidney. And in a clever rhetorical move we learn about Farber's dissatisfaction with his career as a pathologist.  Mukherjee uses descriptive details to establish the pathology lab as a place of "dead things," embalming fluid, tissues, specimens in jars creating a parallel between the lab and Farber's feelings about his work stating that Farber feels "trapped, embalmed in his own glassy cabinet" (12).

Notice how the structure of the sentence, "Instead of squinting at inert specimens under his lens, he would try to leap into the life of the clinics upstairs--from the microscopic world that he knew so well into the magnified real world of patients and illnesses," juxtaposes details about the way that Farber feels about being a pathologist with his perception of the way that he could be using his skills.


SQUINTING AT INERT SPECIMENS VS. LEAPING INTO THE LIFE OF THE CLINIC

MICROSCOPIC WORLD OF PATHOLOGY VS. MAGNIFIED REAL WORLD

BASEMENT, EMBALMING FLUID, JARS VS. PATIENTS AND ILLNESSES UPSTAIRS

That kind of thing right there, Dear Students, that kind of craftsmanship is the reason we are reading this book.  If you don't pay attention to  Mukherjee's syntax (sentence structure), you really will be missing out.

So, here we are as readers with Farber in 1947, and--WATCH OUT--because Mukherjee is about to throw us back to 1845 with the likes of Bennett and Virchow and the discovery of leukemia.  There is Mukherjee using "the past to explain the present." In this case, (I always want to call Sidney Farber Stanley Farber...I'll probably slip from time to time) Sidney Farber and his aminopterin.

I love the way that Mukherjee tries to get inside Virchow's head by posing questions that Virchow must have been asking during his research:  "What of the massively enlarged spleen?"

Ahhhh...here's some Fault in our Stars: "Omnis cellula e cellula."

I noticed in the section about poor Maria Speyer, that Mukherjee uses words like "galloping" and "relentless" to describe her disease.  This polysyllabic choice in diction establishes a rhythm that brings to mind the beating hooves of the Horsemen of the Apocalypse.  Dramatic?  Maybe.  But, so is cancer. 

Mukherjee next pitches us way forward to Carla and her problem of "immunological poverty" and then circles back (or is it still forward?) to Farber.  Are you dizzy yet?  Mukherjee keeps this carnival ride going for 450 more pages.  So, fasten your seatbelts.

I noticed Mukherjee's sensitivity to his non-scientist reading audience with his definition of science and the "counting bit" on p. 19. And then, just when we had forgotten all about the long-awaited package: there it is.  And, as if that weren't enough of a cliffhanger, Mukherjee ends this section with the magnitude of the impact that this package will have on the study of cancer.

These are all the things that I noticed in this section.  Anyone have something to add? Any sentences or choices in diction that you found interesting or well-written?  Any compelling details about the content?  Any questions?  I'll post about the "Monster" section later today.  I have a day of catch up due to yesterday's neglect.  Sometimes life just demands to be lived :)

Friday, June 27, 2014

So, it was in the stars today

....that I go see the movie adaptation of the John Green novel that is relevant to our summer reading. "Why," you might be asking, "is this relevant to the first seven or so pages of our book?"  Well, you see, it's just this: within those first few pages and throughout the entire work, Mukerjee refers to Susan Sontag's work, Illness as Metaphor. And if you've seen the film, The Fault in our Stars, you know that one of the characters carries a cigarette around as a metaphor.  You also know that the main character, Hazel Lancaster, goes to visit her favorite author wearing a t-shirt that illustrates the philosophy of Magritte (Google him. He died of pancreatic cancer) because, as she says, the author "referred to him at least fifty times in the book."  It reminded me of Mukherjee's repeated incorporation of Sontag's work into his book.  We get the first dose of Sontag immediately after the dedication page.  The content is appropriate as he will open the "biography" with the story of Carla Reed, who must "identify herself as" a citizen "of that other place".  That place being the "kingdom of the sick."

Did you see how I just blended that quotation in up there?  A lot of our work together will involve making you all masters at blending quoted material into your ideas. Maybe you've mastered that already.  If so, great.....we can spend our time somewhere else.

Next, Mukherjee presents some statistics to give his readers perspective about the magnitude of the disease and then, it is Mukherjee's turn to share with us, in the Author's Note, the story of his creation.  His purpose, his motivation.  He establishes the personification of cancer and identifies two central characters: Sidney Farber and Mary Lasker. Mukherjee establishes his credibility as an author, his ethos, by acknowledging that his work is the result of everything that came before it and him.  And he discusses his personal investment.  An author needs his readers to-most desirably-like him, or- at the least- respect him long enough to listen to his argument.  And that is what we get in Mukherjee's author's note.  He makes the reader privy to his thinking, his intentions and humbles himself by giving credit where credit is due.

So, now, The Prologue.  Students who read this last summer reported that their favorite parts of this book, which by the way looks to be the same size and even color as Hazel's favorite book in the film; my copy of Emperor looks just like her copy of The Imperial Affliction, are the narratives.

To tell you about all of the things I love in this section, I need to make a list.  They are as follows:

1.  The structure of this sentence:  "Its pace, its acuity, its breathtaking, inexorable arc of growth forces rapid, often drastic decisions; it is terrifying to experience, terrifying to observe, and terrifying to treat"(3).  Will you just look at that craftsmanship?

2.  The personification of the hospital: "a patient with acute leukemia still sends a shiver down the hospital's spine" (3)

3.  How about Mukherjee's use of questions to present his material? They start on page 5.  He is a scientist after all.  And science begins with questions.  The search for answers follows and then there are more questions.  Mukherjee will continue this throughout the entire book to give us insight into the minds of scientists and doctors.  He uses their questions to lay out the narrative of their successes and failures thereby illustrating in his narrative the process of scientific inquiry.

4.  This book is full of literary allusions and examples and Mukherjee's reference to the work of Solzhenitsyn is the first of many.  In this case, Mukherjee uses it to personify cancer: "The illness strips him of his identity.  It dresses him in a patient's smock (a tragicomically cruel costume, no less blighting that a prisoner's jumpsuit) and assumes absolute control of his actions" (4) 

5.  In the beginning of the book, he makes all these casual references to people who will appear prominently later in the book:  Atossa, Halstedt....

6.  And then he returns to Carla, and having set cancer up as a prison with the Solzhenitsyn bit, he-a citizen of the kingdom of the well- leaves her, "sealed" in her new prison with the "whoosh" of the door.

Beautiful, man.
And so was the film, The Fault in our Stars.  There are so many subtle references to ideas from Emperor that I have to believe (and, okay I want to believe) that John Green put them there on purpose.  As we read together it would be cool if you would let me know if you notice anything linking the two.

Please post your comments and questions.  We will all understand this book much better if we engage in some discussion.  Don't be one of those poor students on test day who wishes they would have engaged in some discussion.

I know this was long.  Not all my entries will be that way.

Tomorrow: "A Suppuration of Blood"

Today We Start

How did this day come so quickly?

If you are going to tread this path with me this summer, then today you should read all of the pages that contain quotations as a preface to the book, the Author's Note and the Prologue.  This puts us just over the seven page a day requirement, but it seems to me a more natural "chunk" of text to discuss. (I really hope there is some discussion this year.)

I am going to try to post something a little fancy later in the day today so that you can compare the content that you gleaned from these pages with the content that seemed noteworthy to me.  So, go read your pages, and then, I am thinking it would be safe for you to look for another post maybe right after dinner before you head out for your fun summer evening activities. 

If you were going to try to practice one of the reading strategies that we discussed at the workshop, I think "previewing the text" might be a natural choice for today. 

More later.

Warmly,
Mrs. McAllister

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Summer Reading Workshop 6/4-6/6/14

This is a resource I handed out today to those folks who attended the reading workshop.  I would welcome any comments from today's participants about the usefulness of the session.  Also, if you have remaining questions after today's session, comment here and I will do my best to provide you with timely answers.

Also, if you have not signed up for a session and still want to attend, you can join us Thursday or Friday after school.

Here's the handout:

The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer
Purpose for Reading
“ Some books are to be tasted, others to be swallowed, and some few to be chewed and digested: that is, some books are to be read only in parts, others to be read, but not curiously, and some few to be read wholly, and with diligence and attention.”
― Francis Bacon, The Essays

This book is one, as Bacon says, “to be digested…to be read wholly, and with diligence and attention.”
We are reading this text because I want you to have some experience with a complex text- a highly complex text- going into AP Lang.  It is a model of skillful writing and craftsmanship and an exemplar of synthesized writing.
Read  to comprehend the content, to learn about the history of cancer and the treatment of it. Read to internalize the struggles and setbacks and the victories of the “characters” in the “story.”  There will be a test on our first day of class to keep you accountable for the reading.  It will be multiple choice and will cover significant discoveries, significant people and significant events in the history of the disease and in the search for a cure.
Read to witness the rhetorical choices of the author including his use of questioning, transitions, anecdotes, description, figurative language, in particular the rich presence of allusions, and the quotations that Mukherjee uses to enrich the content of each section.
Read to practice the strategies presented in the workshop.  You don’t have to do them all every time you read.  Choose a few per section.  Discover what works best for you so that you can make those strategies a permanent part of your reading process.
Read to track the recursive text structure and the repeated content as “medicine and science (Mukherjee seems to lump these into one entity in his quotation) has a conversation with its past.”   
Read to document the places that strike you as particularly interesting.  Keep track of them so that you have some choices when you later write an essay that uses Emperor as the “springboard” for your thinking.


 Also, here is a list of reading strategies to practice while reading:
Setting A Reading Purpose
Choosing A Reading Process
Previewing
Identifying and Evaluating Roadblocks
Tolerating Ambiguity
Clarifying
Using Context
Making Connections
Chunking
Visualizing
Listening for Voice
Questioning
Predicting
Organizing Ideas and Information
Paraphrasing
Getting the Gist
Summarizing
Sequencing
Comparing and Contrasting
Identifying Cause and Effect
Using Evidence
Rereading
Writing to Clarify Understanding
Writing to Consolidate Learning

Here are some links to a few helpful videos that we watched.

http://thestoryofcancer.org/
http://www.grossmont.edu/english/onebookonecampus/VideoAuthorBook.html